In response to a recent post, "You Really Are Black," a trusted reader commented: "i find that rarely, if ever, do i read of your struggles with 'whiteness' or 'danish-ness'. that part of your identity seems completely uncomplicated and free and natural in its expression, whereas your relationship to blackness is . . . fraught. maybe i am missing something. i just find it curious."
Her comment so intrigued me I emailed her immediately: "[This] is really insightful. I’m going to mull this over a bit -- I would say mostly it was because I didn’t know about being black (myself or what it meant for others) until I was about 11. In a way, I suppose I associate my Danish-ness (and I wouldn’t ever have called it whiteness until moving to the States at 11) with childish innocence. My blackness was something that I had to learn and also that stripped me of my Danish-ness ---meaning suddenly my Danish-ness didn’t matter – I was simply light-skinned-ed and also ignorant of what my culture “should” be. Hmmm . . . those are off-the-cuff impressions. But this sure is making me think – as soon as I figure it out enough – these thoughts –I hope deeper thoughts may show up in a post . . . "
After a week of mulling, I am still not able Iand am bothered by my inability) to shape a better answer. I am struck by her use of the word "fraught"--(adj. 1. Filled with a specified element or elements; charged. 2. Fully provided. (That one doesn't fit; but then check out the next one.) 3. Marked by distress; upsetting.) In terms of my writing, I do focus on the difficulty of taking on blackness (or black identity). I suppose that the distress comes from trying to come to terms with the difference between what it means for others and what it means for myself.
My Danish-ness becomes more and more complicated as I grow older. I have become more and more American--living here, losing my accent, and language bit by bit. Still, unlike my "black identity," it feels more like the bedrock of who I am --it is the deepest soil within me.
James Baldwin spoke of leaving the United States for France, and suddenly finding a new freedom for his thoughts. " . . . [W]hen I hear 'Ignore race.' Well, it took me a long time to do that, and perhaps I would never have been able to do it if I hadn't left America. I know I wouldn't have been able to do it if I hadn't left America . . . I realized one day that somebody asked me about a friend of mine who, in fact, when I thought about it, is probably North African, but I really did not remember whether he was white or black. It simply had never occurred to me. The question had never been in my mind. Never in my mind. I really had a terrible tiime. I suddenly felt as though I were lost. My whole frame of reference all the years I was growing up had been black and white. You know, you always knew who was white and who was black. But suddenly I didn't have it; suddenly that frame of reference had gone. And in a funny way--and I don't know how to make sense of this--as far as I could tell, as far as I can tell till this hour, once that has happened to you, it never comes back."
I grew up for the most part overseas (on military bases or near them). I not only Ignored Race, I didn't even learn about the black-white frame of reference until age 11--and when it happened, it was like a hood came down on my thoughts. I had to suddenly recognize this thing called being black and conform my thoughts to what that meant for other people. (I mean this was the unspoken directive of both black and white people.)
My experience was further complicated by the fact that I identified as American. In my naivete or foolishness, I was able to be both American and Danish. Being black it seemed, suddenly provided no room for either of those identities. I needed to know about race to 1) demonstrate my allegiance (that I was not better than other black people); 2) keep me safe (so that I would be taught about how to avoid, recognize, deal with racism); and 3) keep me in my "place" (so that I would not get too big for my britches--black and white lessons). So, yes, fraught. Racial identity, a backward racial frame of reference, foisted upon you, my relationship to that experience is certainly fraught. But is this experience so different than many others'--meaning mono-racial people of color? Is it any different than anyone --mono or multiracial--living the Mixed experience?
Recent Comments